Heinnies Restaurant

Elkhart, IN 

Heinnies Restaurant – Elkhart County

best elkhart restaurants

Located in Elkhart, Indiana, Heinnies is a popular restaurant that serves delicious food at affordable prices. And the best part is the serving sizes are generous so you really are getting what you’re paying for.

Heinnies is a small town restaurant with friendly atmosphere and if you visit frequent you’ll likely get to know the servers and owner.

There is bar seating in the back right when you walk in, or you can turn left and find traditional dining.

It’s a unique experience as the interior is designed like a horse barn with horse stalls, so tables will be separated by the horse stall walls to offer some privacy to your dinner party.

The drink menu offers a selection of beers, wines, and cocktails. There is also a kids menu if you’re bringing children to dinner!

Overall, Heinnies offers great food, a fun atmosphere, and friendly service, tucked away on the south side of Elkhart, Indiana.

Heinnies Menu

Appetizers: Buffalo Wings, Potato Wedges, Zucchini Sticks, Onion Rings, Pretzel Bites, Mozzarella Sticks, Shrimp Cocktail, and more.

Salads: Chef Salad, Chicken Breast Salad, House Salad, Steak Salad

Soups: Homemade Chili

Sandwiches: Chicken Parmesan, Pork Tenderloin, Italian Sausage, Big Ham & Cheese, Chicken Breast, Buffalo Chicken, BLT

Entres: Angus Filet, Ribeye, Surf n Turf, Pork Chop, New York Strip, Salmon, Shrimp, Haddock, Smothered Chicken, Chicken Fingers, and various burgers (Cheese Burgers, Bacon, Buffalo, Heinnie, etc.)

Heinnies Weekly Specials:

  • Monday: 1/4 lb Cheeseburger with half order of fries
  • Tuesday: Fried Chicken Dinner
  • Wednesday: Sirloin for two (32oz)
  • Thursday: 10oz Filet
  • Friday: Prime Rib
  • Saturday: Prime Rib
  • Sunday: CLOSED

Where is Heinnies Restaurant Located?

Heinnies is located on Lusher Avenue, just south of the railroad tracks. You’ll likely turn onto Lusher from State Road 19 (Nappanee Street) or from Main Street.

Address: 1743 W Lusher Ave, Elkhart, IN 46517

Heinnies Restaurant Hours

  • Monday: 3pm – 9pm
  • Tuesday: 3pm – 9pm
  • Wednesday: 3pm – 9pm
  • Thursday: 3pm – 9pm
  • Friday: 3pm – 9:30pm
  • Saturday: 4:30pm – 9:30pm
  • Sunday: Closed

Phone Number

If you’d like to make reservations or call for carryout orders, you can do so by dialing (574) 522-9101

nick foy real estate elkhart

Moving to Elkhart?

We recommend giving Realtor Nick Foy a call. He works with RE/MAX Oak Crest Realty and will drop what he’s doing to pick up the phone and serve your housing needs!

You can give Real Estate Agent Nick Foy a call today at 574-387-2501 or email him at NickFoyHomes@gmail.com

Learn More About Elkhart County – Northern Indiana

Photo Slideshow

Quilt Gardens
Ruthmere Museum
Nibco Water Park
Super Hero Museum
The Artisan Restaurant
Previous slide
Next slide

Video Tour of Elkhart, Indiana


Check out the best restaurants in town.
Click Here

Bars & Breweries

Check out the best bars in town.
Click Here


See what events are happening in Elkhart.
Click Here