Antonio’s Italian Restaurant

Elkhart, Indiana

Antonio’s Italian Restaurant

antonios elkhart in

Antonio’s Italian Restaurant is one of the go to spots in Elkhart for Italian food, with a warm inviting atmosphere, friendly staff, and a great selection of wine to go with your meal.

The owner, Paul Cataldo, is an International Pizza Champion, having perfected his craft at making delicious pizzas. You’ll definitely want to stop by and try out one of Antonio’s pizzas!

One of the main reasons locals love visiting Antonio’s is the family atmosphere. The Cataldo’s treat everyone like family and odds are you’ll bump into a Cataldo when eating there for dinner. Owner Paul, walks around greeting customers regularly when he’s not in the back helping prepare food for his customers.

The scene inside makes you feel like you’re on a trip to Italy. Italian decor and design runs throughout the different eating rooms and there’s a full service bar available for seating as well.

Make sure to try out their Italian wines. They have quite the selection. Beer and cocktails are also available.

Antonio’s Italian Menu

Appetizers: Antipasto, Burratta, Mozzarella Sticks, Calamari

Soups & Salads: Chicken Tortellini Soup, Antonio’s House Salad, Eggplant Arugula Salad

Pizzas: Cheese, Pepperoni, Ham, Sausage, Italian Meatball, Italian Sausage, Bacon, Pineapple, Jalapenos, and more specialty pizzas. Sizes range from 10″, 12″, 14″, 16″, and 18″ and you can also order stuffed pizza too.

Pasta: Spaghetti, Penne, Alfredo, Fettuccini, Rigatoni, Linguini, Angel Hair, Soccotini, and more 

Entres: Chicken Parmesan, Pope’s Chicken, Ribs, Lemon Barry Salmon, Lasagna Bolognese 

Where is Antonio’s Italian Restaurant Located?

Antonio’s Italian Restaurant is located in Elkhart, Indiana off of Goshen Avenue, just north of Toledo Road. It’s on the south east side of town.

Address: 1105 Goshen Ave, Elkhart, IN 46516

Antonio’s Hours

  • Monday: Closed
  • Tuesday: Closed
  • Wednesday: 4pm – 9pm
  • Thursday: 4pm – 9pm
  • Friday: 4pm – 10pm
  • Saturday: 4pm – 10pm
  • Sunday: Closed

Phone Number

If you’d like to make reservations you can do so by dialing (574) 295-8424

nick foy real estate elkhart

Moving to Elkhart?

We recommend giving Realtor Nick Foy a call. He works with RE/MAX Oak Crest Realty and will drop what he’s doing to pick up the phone and serve your housing needs!

You can give Real Estate Agent Nick Foy a call today at 574-387-2501 or email him at

Learn More About Elkhart County – Northern Indiana

Photo Slideshow

Quilt Gardens
Ruthmere Museum
Nibco Water Park
Super Hero Museum
The Artisan Restaurant
Previous slide
Next slide

Video Tour of Elkhart, Indiana


Check out the best restaurants in town.
Click Here

Bars & Breweries

Check out the best bars in town.
Click Here


See what events are happening in Elkhart.
Click Here